About

UP Harriman Box Car by Westerfield


In 2022, I started a Union Pacific Harriman 40′ box car by Westerfield (1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP) when life, uh, found a way to impose a modeling freeze. In 2025, this project was resurrected.

Stage 1: 2022 Assembly

By my third resin kit, initial assembly was much smoother than before. It helped that this was a high-quality kit with very thin resin flash:

Unassembled parts for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP
Unassembled parts for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP
Small parts for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP, showing the thin flash.
Small parts for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP, showing the thin flash.

End and side assembly was routine, but the grabirons were their normal level of tedious:

Pre-assembled, unpainted ends for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Pre-assembled, unpainted ends for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Pre-assembled, unpainted sides for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Pre-assembled, unpainted sides for Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

Dimensions of the sides and underframe matched well:

Underframe of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP with car weights showing and the car side attached away from the viewer.
Underframe of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP with car weights showing and the car side attached away from the viewer.
Underframe of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP with car weights showing both car sides attached.
Underframe of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP with car weights showing both car sides attached.

Record Scratch

Spongebob Squarepants meme reading 2.5 Years Later...

Stage 2: 2025 Assembly

The state of Union Pacific shipping via my house saw a substantial increase in 2025 with the resumption of construction of this box car. First I took stock of the condition of the kit after being packed up for a while:

Partially assembled, unpainted Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP showing the undetailed underframe.
Partially assembled, unpainted Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP showing the undetailed underframe.

The Sergent extended-length couplers seemed necessary because of the thick coupler pocket holes, but now extend just a little further out than would be ideal. This style of coupler can now be gotten from Prototype Couplers model EC87P100KH.

Roof attachment happened off-camera:

Side view of Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP, unpainted with roof and center roofwalk attached in addition to scale couplers.
Side view of Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP, unpainted with roof and center roofwalk attached in addition to scale couplers.
Side view of Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP, unpainted with roof and center roofwalk attached in addition to scale couplers. Visible box showing the kit number.
Side view of Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP, unpainted with roof and center roofwalk attached in addition to scale couplers. Visible box showing the kit number.

End walks came together like normal, but I could feel my rustiness:

View of resin roof cross-walk with attached brass braces tacked to a holder.
View of resin roof cross-walk with attached brass braces tacked to a holder.

Still getting back into the groove, I failed to document construction of the brake gear and underframe. Here it is in the completed model. Note the uneven grabirons, which are more visible from this angle:

Underframe view of assembled, unpainted Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Underframe view of assembled, unpainted Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

The only slightly weird thing about the underframe is the angle of the brake rods at the end of the levers.

Next, the brake staff. The instructions said to have it raised 6 scale feet above the roof, in my interpretation. This feels like it is way too tall, but I went with it for now and may revise later:

Nearly complete Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP showing the brake end with the rod installed- it is too tall- but no brake wheel yet.
Nearly complete Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP showing the brake end with the rod installed- it is too tall- but no brake wheel yet.
A end of the nearly complete model Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
A end of the nearly complete model Westerfield 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

Completed Assembly

All in all, I made one minor visible mistake in 2022 with the grabirons, and the rest of the many imperfections are vintage 2025 lack of practice.

Side view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Side view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

Other than the high brake wheel, things are looking ok from the side. On the top, we can see a few minor blemishes from misapplied CA:

Top view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Top view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

The cut levers were a little too flimsy after sanding and one of them died. Luckily, I had some spare Yarmouth cut levers – not identical, but close enough for this model. The brake hoses are Cal Scale.

Note how the roofwalk end supports (white styrene) are uneven on both ends:

A end view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
A end view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
B end view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
B end view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

The B end roof cross-walk has an angle that is not quite 90 degrees:

B end top view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
B end top view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Side view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Side view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Side view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Side view of assembled, unpainted 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

Doing the Washing-Up

Now that the model is assembled, it is almost time to prime and paint. But first, let’s wash the model with soapy lukewarm water and perform a critical review of some remaining areas that need improvement on future models.

Washing an HO scale resin model kit.
Washing an HO scale resin model kit.

Critical Review

Decals for the Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Decals for the Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

The Union Pacific is not my primary modeling interest – more on that in a future post – but the prototype for this model is both period and geographically plausible for my era/location of 1939 US centered on Northern New Mexico, reaching to the Pacific coast and the Midwest US. I want to build up my skills to an acceptable level before tackling house road name cars. This kit has been a move in that direction.

The two big areas I want to improve on a future model assembly are grab iron evenness and improvement of glue joints. I am especially bothered by the four corners of the model, which could have used some Tamiya Putty:

A end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
A end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
B end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
B end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Second B end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Second B end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Second A end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40' DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.
Second A end corner of Westerfield kit 1754 B-50-1/2/4 40′ DS BOX CAR, MODERN, 1924 & 1936 LETTERING, UP.

I therefore rate this model as a necessary step demonstrating an intermediate stage of modeling skill toward truly expert modeling.

The next step in this model is painting, naturally. But we have a few other topics to cover before we get there.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *